Candidate 1
Planning & Research
Strengths:
He gives good explanations in his production logs. This shows that he understands the work that he had to do.
He does good research in to films like the 'The Bourne Identity' and the 'The Dark Knight' showing that he was going to make a similar film.
He uses a spider diagram to show his potential thriller ideas this makes it easy to read and its very clear.
Weaknesses:
His thriller ideas are done on a spider diagram so even though they are clear i don't think he has written enough and could have done more.
His production log is very short he doesn't make many points and he starts to hesitates towards the end which shows he is unsure about what he is saying.
The Evaluation of previous students that he did is not presented very well as he just toke pictures of it so its unclear.
He generally doesn't use examples to support the points that he made.
Mark: I gave this part a 12/30 which is just level 3 he could of done better.
Construction
Strengths:
The lighting he uses is good it sets the mood in the scene.
The music he uses matches the scene and the mood the sound effects as well are also good as they help set the mood.
The close-up of his hand is good as it shows us that it's the same person and what previously happened to him.
Weaknesses:
The story is unclear and i don't understand what is going on and the camera shots don't help.
The soundtrack at the start goes on far to long and become boring and loses interest.
At the end it says reloaded and this makes no sense as it doesn't fit what i had just seen.
Mark: I gave it 32/60 which is a level 2.
Evaluation
Strengths:
He annotated the film clip good by using digital technology.
He was to the point and made good points he was able to identify the strengths and weaknesses of his work.
Weaknesses:
The group discussion they had was unclear.
He could have written more and made his points more clear.
Mark: I gave him 12/20 which is a level 3.
Candidate 2
Planning & Research
Strengths:
His planning is good he researches other films that are the same as the genre he wants to do.
He shows the actors that he wants in his film showing pictures and information about them.
He shows a good understanding as he analysis the film 'fight club'.
Weaknesses:
I can't find any weaknesses with this.
Mark: 19/20 level 4
Construction
Strengths:
The editing was good the typewriter effect was good as it related to the scene.
He used a variety of shots i liked the over the shoulder shots as it showed the facial expression of the character and added to the tension.
The Mise-En-scene is plain and simple and adds to the realism of piece.
Weaknesses:
The only weakness was that the dialogue was too low and i could just about hear it.
Mark: 54/60
Evaluation
Strengths:
He includes points from the audience so he hears there strong points about the film.
The presentation of the blogs was good so that everything was clear and easy to understand.
He links all his points to different aspects of his evaluation so everything is linked together.
Weaknesses:
I couldn't find no weakness with his evaluation.
Mark 20/20